The Golden Compass - Is It Really Atheistic, and Should That Affect You Watching the Movie?
Well, with The Golden Compass movie being released this week, I figured I'd make a little entry for it. I've already posted my review of the books (in short, I liked them, but didn't think they were great), so I won't cover that here. Instead, I'll cover a bit of the hoopla surrounding these books being atheistic, and a bit of the silly rationale I've seen from people trying to claim otherwise.
MILD SPOILERS AHEAD - DON'T READ THIS IF YOU WANT DON'T WANT TO KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE STORY
To be blunt, yes, the books are based on an atheistic worldview. I don't think this gives away too much of the plot, since it's revealed about midway through the second book, but in this story, God is not the creator of the universe, but instead the first conscious being to have developed. He's neither omnipotent nor omniscient. He's basically tricked much of the universe into thinking that he was the creator.
Now, I've seen in some reviews of the book, and in some blog comments, people who claim that the books aren't atheistic, because they're about a war on this character claiming to be God, but who wasn't really the Creator. I think those people are missing something - the character in this book that claims to be God, is (in the book) the same character that Christians worship. In other words, the books show a world where Yahweh is not a god. Now, I guess that strictly speaking, these books don't deny the possibility of some type of a god/gods, but there aren't any gods in these books, in the sense that most people would define a god, and the only character claiming to be a god, isn't.
But, just because the books are based on an atheistic worldview, does it mean that they promote atheism? If we accept what Pullman himself said in an interview, no.
As for the atheism, it doesn't matter to me whether people believe in God or not, so I'm not promoting anything of that sort. What I do care about is whether people are cruel or whether they're kind, whether they act for democracy or for tyranny, whether they believe in open-minded enquiry or in shutting the freedom of thought and expression. Good things have been done in the name of religion, and so have bad things; and both good things and bad things have been done with no religion at all. What I care about is the good, wherever it comes from.
There's another way to look at it - the books are fantasy. I'm pretty sure that even Pullman doesn't believe in the universe he created, so it seems a bit silly to claim that he's trying to promote it. It would be like trying to claim that J.K. Rowling was promoting magic in her Harry Potter books (I realize a few people did claim this, but there are also still people who think the earth is flat - some people are just a few cards shy of a full deck). Pullman's universe is just a way to get people thinking about one of the main themes of the books, questioning authority and orthodoxy. What better way is there to illustrate that than to question the ultimate authority?
One other topic I wanted to touch on was the hypocrisy of the people denouncing The Golden Compass for indoctrinating children, but who had no problem with The Chronicles of Narnia. What's the difference? Perhaps I shouldn't be so quick to sling around the term, hypocrite - maybe some of those people do recognize Narnia as indoctrinating children into a Christian worldview, and wouldn't have any problems with people of other religions (or no religion) not letting their children read those books or see the movies based on them.
So, to get to the important question, should you let the atheistic worldview of The Golden Compass influence your decision to watch the movie, or to allow your children to watch the movie? Well, I guess if you're the type of person who avoided Clash of the Titans, because it promoted ancient Greek religion, and you didn't let your children watch it because you were afraid they might start worshipping Zeus, well then, The Golden Compass probably isn't for you. But, if you can enjoy it for what it is, and assuming that the movie adaptation turns out okay (and so far, according to IMDB, it appears to be doing pretty well), then it's probably a movie worth seeing.
Note: Wording in closing paragraph has been slightly modified from original posting, but nothing that changes the overall meaning.
Comments
where can i buy lipitor order lipitor 80mg lipitor uk
Posted by: Pofkzf | March 12, 2024 12:51 PM
cipro ca - cephalexin 250mg pill augmentin us
Posted by: Tjlapj | March 14, 2024 9:53 PM
cipro 1000mg us - how to get keflex without a prescription buy augmentin tablets
Posted by: Nqeoxa | March 14, 2024 10:53 PM
buy flagyl 400mg online - order amoxicillin generic buy zithromax 500mg online
Posted by: Deultu | March 17, 2024 7:10 PM
ciprofloxacin medication - purchase chloramphenicol generic erythromycin 250mg drug
Posted by: Mgnhxd | March 18, 2024 7:24 AM
order valtrex 1000mg online cheap - buy valtrex 1000mg for sale where can i buy acyclovir
Posted by: Dcxbef | March 20, 2024 12:09 AM
ivermectin 3mg oral - cheap sumycin without prescription sumycin over the counter
Posted by: Niezjc | March 20, 2024 10:56 AM
metronidazole drug - cefaclor 250mg cost generic zithromax 250mg
Posted by: Aefoub | March 21, 2024 6:37 PM
ampicillin sale buy acillin cheap cheap amoxil
Posted by: Xlysyu | March 22, 2024 1:15 PM
generic furosemide - capoten 25 mg uk buy capoten sale
Posted by: Phbhaf | March 23, 2024 4:15 PM
buy metformin 1000mg online - order duricef pill lincomycin online order
Posted by: Obcshk | March 26, 2024 6:20 AM
purchase zidovudine for sale - allopurinol 300mg pill
Posted by: Dhqnkz | March 26, 2024 11:06 PM
buy clozaril without prescription - purchase coversyl online cheap brand pepcid
Posted by: Uzsxqq | March 28, 2024 5:10 PM
where to buy quetiapine without a prescription - trazodone price buy eskalith tablets
Posted by: Yqyizq | March 30, 2024 1:56 AM
order clomipramine 25mg generic - order duloxetine 40mg generic sinequan for sale
Posted by: Hotmeb | March 31, 2024 11:40 AM
atarax price - pamelor 25 mg canada endep 25mg oral
Posted by: Voizbo | March 31, 2024 10:34 PM
purchase amoxil - buy erythromycin without a prescription order ciprofloxacin pills
Posted by: Uxtdvt | April 4, 2024 12:43 PM
purchase augmentin for sale - zyvox price buy baycip generic
Posted by: Vopvyj | April 4, 2024 1:25 PM
buy cleocin 300mg without prescription - buy suprax 200mg for sale order chloramphenicol without prescription
Posted by: Epenpd | April 10, 2024 12:40 AM
buy azithromycin 500mg - ciprofloxacin 500mg brand order ciprofloxacin 500 mg online cheap
Posted by: Xhnesq | April 10, 2024 1:48 PM
generic stromectol for humans - eryc online order cefaclor pill
Posted by: Cplcst | April 13, 2024 6:23 AM
ventolin inhalator price - promethazine 25mg drug purchase theophylline for sale
Posted by: Yxewfg | April 13, 2024 3:33 PM
desloratadine online order - buy generic desloratadine over the counter ventolin inhalator price
Posted by: Gfwlsl | April 16, 2024 2:04 AM
purchase medrol pills - generic azelastine buy astelin nasal spray for sale
Posted by: Kntzyw | April 16, 2024 7:29 AM
glyburide medication - buy generic glipizide 10mg buy generic dapagliflozin
Posted by: Wsddik | April 17, 2024 11:15 PM
purchase repaglinide - purchase prandin sale purchase empagliflozin
Posted by: Spvuqa | April 20, 2024 2:11 AM
oral metformin 500mg - purchase acarbose for sale order precose 50mg generic
Posted by: Fzxuog | April 20, 2024 12:19 PM
lamisil pills - oral lamisil where to buy griseofulvin without a prescription
Posted by: Iiqxsx | April 22, 2024 6:37 PM
buy generic rybelsus - buy DDAVP desmopressin cost
Posted by: Vvxmtd | April 23, 2024 10:20 AM
buy nizoral 200 mg without prescription - order itraconazole 100 mg online purchase itraconazole pill
Posted by: Kcnxgy | April 24, 2024 9:22 PM
buy famvir 500mg for sale - buy acyclovir generic valcivir for sale
Posted by: Pyffsl | April 26, 2024 1:06 PM
buy lanoxin 250 mg for sale - buy digoxin tablets furosemide 100mg tablet
Posted by: Nwlzkq | April 27, 2024 12:07 AM
microzide 25mg canada - zestril 2.5mg over the counter zebeta for sale online
Posted by: Facnjo | April 29, 2024 1:47 AM
buy lopressor online cheap - nifedipine 10mg price nifedipine 30mg generic
Posted by: Uhbkiq | April 29, 2024 4:08 PM
buy cheap nitroglycerin - nitroglycerin generic valsartan tablet
Posted by: Xhwxbt | May 1, 2024 12:55 AM
rosuvastatin online opportunity - ezetimibe buy corpse caduet online blast
Posted by: Blnbdk | May 3, 2024 5:11 PM
zocor acquaintance - gemfibrozil pack lipitor drift
Posted by: Aiwpff | May 4, 2024 1:03 PM
acne treatment kindle - acne treatment complicate acne treatment swing
Posted by: Pvuopq | May 20, 2024 8:10 AM
inhalers for asthma myth - asthma medication respond asthma treatment trick
Posted by: Uadzao | May 21, 2024 12:25 AM
treatment for uti bargain - uti treatment mother uti antibiotics remind
Posted by: Jkpxwg | May 22, 2024 4:29 AM
pills for treat prostatitis immense - prostatitis pills union prostatitis medications cliff
Posted by: Rdaimc | May 22, 2024 8:23 PM