« Young Earth Creationism - Is It a Modern Phenomenon? | Main | Fastnacht Day »

'Scientific' Facts

MicroscopeSometimes, a term that you've heard your whole life suddenly seems strange, That's how it is for me and 'scientific facts'. When you think about it, that phrase seems a bit redundant. If something is true, it's a fact. It's that simple. It doesn't matter how you came to know it. If a statement lines up with objective reality, it's a fact.

What does it add to describe a fact as 'scientific'? I guess the first thing is to understand is what's meant by science. Generally, there are two related meanings to the word. The first is that it's a method. We should all know this method from grade school - come up with an explanation, gather evidence to test the explanation, refine your explanation, and repeat. The second is the body of knowledge we've learned through that method. But the thing is, everything that has an objective answer can be examined through science.

Consider an example. Some would consider the Earth orbiting the sun a 'scientific' fact. We as humanity may have learned about it through science, and we as individuals may have learned it in science class, but it doesn't change the fact that it's true. It's not as if the Sun used to orbit the Earth until Galileo came along. Can't we just call it a plain old fact?

There are a couple reasons I bring this up. One is for the people who like to point out that science can't tell us anything with absolute certainty, and therefore science doesn't deal in facts (like this exchange I had). When you consider things like solipsism and Last Thursdayism, you have to grant that for fact to have any meaning, it must mean very high level of certainty, and not 100% absolute certainty. Going by that definition, science certainly does deal in facts.

The other is for the people who think of science as something separate, as not really describing things as part of their world. To them, it may be a 'scientific' fact that evolution occurs, but but in their world, science is wrong, so describing evolution as 'scientific' means it may not have actually occurred.

Oh well, I'm not be expressing myself as clearly as I'd like, but it's late on a Friday, and I'm about ready for some supper and a beer. I guess the main point I'm trying to get across is something I already said in the first paragraph. Calling something a 'scientific' fact is redundant. Statements are either true or not, and if they're true, then they're facts. Since we can study everything with an objective answer through science, it really doesn't add anything to describe any facts as scientific. If they're not scientific, they're not really facts to begin with.


Added 2010-02-01 I thought about this a bit over the weekend, and realized that that last sentence might come off as a bit smug. So, I thought that maybe I should list a couple examples.

As the first example, consider the claim that Hawaii is the 50th state of the U.S. To look at this scientifically, we need to gather evidence to support that claim. We could start off by looking at current legal documents, which show that Hawaii is definitely a state. We could move on to archived documents, and find the Hawaii Admission Act, which shows when Hawaii became a state. We could move on to find documents of when each of the previous 49 states became states. We could study newspaper articles from each of those periods for additional confirmation. After studying all that evidence, then we could say that it is a 'scientific' fact that Hawaii is the 50th state of the U.S.

Next, let's move on to something that some would think was a bit more subjective. Consider the claim that I love my wife and daughter. To test this, people could observe my behavior around my family, and the actions I commit in relation to my wife and daughter. They could study my involuntary facial expressions, to see how I react around them. They could observe my behavior when they're not around, looking for signs of loneliness, or observing how I talk about them. So, even the claim that I love my wife and daughter can be considered to be a 'scientific' fact, since we can use the scientific method to investigate it.

That's what I mean when I say that all facts worth talking about are scientific. Sometimes, we only practice rudimentary forms of the scientific method to determine their veracity, but, at least in principle, the scientific method can be applied to them.

Comments

Good points.

Unfortunately, there seems to be such a lack of science education that people imagine a divide between "scientific facts" and "common sense facts".

In addition, people with a religious bent often need to see things as being absolutely true. It is difficult for them to understand the idea that we can never be absolutely certain about anything.

buy atorvastatin 10mg online buy lipitor generic order atorvastatin 10mg without prescription

lipitor 80mg tablet lipitor order order atorvastatin 40mg pill

purchase cipro for sale - order ciprofloxacin pill augmentin 375mg canada

buy cheap cipro - order ciprofloxacin 1000mg online augmentin 625mg oral

order flagyl 400mg for sale - cleocin online order buy azithromycin paypal

ciplox online order - order erythromycin sale erythromycin 250mg oral

order valtrex without prescription - order starlix 120 mg online zovirax 800mg sale

ivermectin medicine - buy sumycin pills sumycin 250mg price

buy flagyl 400mg sale - flagyl 400mg canada buy azithromycin 250mg

ampicillin generic where can i buy acillin buy amoxicillin for sale

order generic lasix 40mg - buy tacrolimus 1mg pills order captopril 25 mg pill

oral glycomet - order generic cipro buy lincocin 500 mg pill

zidovudine 300 mg pills - epivir 100 mg pills purchase allopurinol without prescription

clozapine medication - coversum medication famotidine buy online

buy quetiapine medication - effexor 150mg sale eskalith generic

how to get anafranil without a prescription - buy imipramine online cheap pill sinequan 25mg

hydroxyzine 10mg ca - lexapro 20mg oral endep 10mg oral

cheap amoxil - erythromycin order cipro over the counter

order amoxiclav sale - buy generic linezolid online purchase baycip generic

cleocin 300mg for sale - chloramphenicol tablets buy chloromycetin medication

zithromax ca - tindamax 300mg pill ciprofloxacin 500 mg over the counter

stromectol 6 mg - ivermectin 3mg tabs buy cefaclor 250mg without prescription

albuterol price - purchase albuterol generic order theophylline without prescription

where to buy clarinex without a prescription - order desloratadine ventolin uk

buy methylprednisolone us - buy cetirizine online cheap buy azelastine 10 ml without prescription

buy prandin 1mg online cheap - order empagliflozin 10mg without prescription jardiance 10mg generic

glucophage ca - losartan order online acarbose usa

lamisil price - purchase fulvicin generic purchase grifulvin v for sale

semaglutide 14mg usa - semaglutide 14mg price DDAVP over the counter

order nizoral 200mg online - order itraconazole 100mg pills purchase sporanox sale

famvir 250mg over the counter - famciclovir pills buy valcivir pill

order digoxin for sale - buy digoxin no prescription furosemide brand

order lopressor 50mg generic - olmesartan 20mg cheap buy nifedipine 30mg generic

buy nitroglycerin without a prescription - order combipres online cheap diovan 80mg sale

simvastatin coin - lipitor pot lipitor drown

rosuvastatin gaunt - pravastatin online kiss caduet raise

acne treatment laughter - acne treatment feather acne treatment french

asthma medication being - asthma medication bile inhalers for asthma marvel

treatment for uti constant - uti antibiotics assemble uti antibiotics queen

prostatitis medications idiot - prostatitis medications sake pills for treat prostatitis comfort

Post a comment


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jefflewis.net/blog/jlnet-tb.cgi/287

Archives

Selling Out