Difference Between ID Proponents and Theistic Evolutionists
For lack of time, I'm once again going to recycle my comments from a comment thread on another site for this week's blog entry.
Some of the more extreme atheists whose writings I've read seem to want to lump those that accept theistic evolution into the same group as those that accept Intelligent Design (ID). In a very broad sense, I can understand the reasoning, but I think there is an important distinction between the two concepts. Here is the first of two comments I left in a thread discussing this issue.
I know I'm late to the party (I was on vacation), but I'll have to agree with the posters who've said that theistic evolution is not nearly the same thing as intelligent design. I know ID advocates are usually pretty vague on what ID actually entails, and it's a big tent, but here are a couple quotes from Of Pandas and People, the ID textbook that was going to be used in Dover (this is recycled from another comment thread [discussed on this site here]).First, in discussing tetrapod evolution on page 22, the book said:
Instead, fossil types are fully formed and functional when they first appear in the fossil record. For example, we don't find creatures that are partly fish and partly something else, leading gradually, in the dozens of characteristics which they exhibit, to today's fish. Instead, fish have all the characteristics of today's fish from the earliest known fish fossils, reptiles in the record have all the characteristics of present-day reptiles, and so on.In discussing the incompleteness of the fossil record on page 25, the book said:
There is, however, another possibility science leaves open to us, one based on sound inferences from the experience of our senses. It is the possibility that an intelligent cause made fully-formed and functional creatures, which later left their traces in the rocks.That's quite a bit different from theistic evolution, where people believe that evolution occurs just like it really does, but that God's nudged the process somehow.
As others have pointed out, it's hard for a theist to accept evolution and not believe in theistic evolution. It's like the old joke of the guy caught in a flood on his roof. Most theists see God being involved in everything, so it's no surprise that they think he was involved in evolution, as well, even if they don't have an explanation for the exact mechanism. As long as theistic teachers stick to the secular explanations of topics in school, I don't see it as a huge problem.
After a couple people posted comments disagreeing with me, I posted another comment.
SteveM,You're right. There is a possibility that somebody could be a deist. But honestly, how many deists are there in this country? Most people who have been indoctrinated into Christianity believe in an active god who intervenes in the universe.
JacobCH,Theistic evolution is not functionally the same thing as ID. As I pointed out with the quotes above, and as most people already know, ID is little more than creationism that refuses to unambiguously state that God is the creator. It's a tactic to get creationism taught in schools. Theistic evolution is for people who have been indoctrinated into believing in an interventionist god, but who are rational enough to recognize that evolution must have happened.
Look at it this way, to an ID advocate, if you take away the 'designer', evolution is impossible. The designer has to be there to poof irreducibly complex systems into existence, or add specified complexity, or whatever other gobbledygook they come up with. To someone who accepts theistic evolution, if you take away the god, evolution continues to happen. It's just that without the god's guidance, evolution may not have resulted in the organisms we have now, particularly humans. Yes, the god is superfluous in that case, but that's what theistic evolution is. Whereas ID tries to force the evidence to fit God, theistic evolution tries to force God to fit the evidence.
I agree that if you just drop God it makes the whole thing easier, but that indoctrination can be really hard to get past.
Comments
atorvastatin 40mg over the counter buy atorvastatin 40mg online cheap oral lipitor 20mg
Posted by: Wxephf | March 12, 2024 12:45 PM
baycip medication - buy ciprofloxacin 500mg generic order augmentin 375mg pill
Posted by: Ntqlce | March 13, 2024 8:48 PM
baycip pills - buy augmentin generic amoxiclav online
Posted by: Eqsvqh | March 14, 2024 9:34 PM
buy ciprofloxacin 500mg generic - order generic tindamax 500mg buy erythromycin 250mg without prescription
Posted by: Nbegnk | March 16, 2024 11:22 PM
order flagyl 200mg - cleocin drug zithromax 250mg over the counter
Posted by: Cjqscq | March 17, 2024 5:46 PM
stromectol 3 mg - cheap co-amoxiclav tablets sumycin 500mg brand
Posted by: Gjiskl | March 19, 2024 3:22 AM
valtrex 500mg drug - order generic nemasole acyclovir 400mg uk
Posted by: Ckeksk | March 19, 2024 10:39 PM
order ampicillin generic amoxil tablets amoxicillin brand
Posted by: Adpppc | March 21, 2024 7:22 AM
metronidazole for sale online - generic cleocin buy zithromax paypal
Posted by: Zwtyyv | March 21, 2024 5:28 PM
buy furosemide 40mg online cheap - order coumadin 2mg without prescription buy capoten 25 mg online cheap
Posted by: Yfscyu | March 23, 2024 2:44 PM
order glucophage 1000mg generic - buy generic epivir online buy lincomycin pills
Posted by: Ewblzp | March 24, 2024 11:45 PM
buy zidovudine sale - allopurinol 300mg over the counter
Posted by: Dtheen | March 26, 2024 9:37 PM
buy clozaril 100mg sale - buy famotidine 40mg for sale brand famotidine
Posted by: Aefzjz | March 27, 2024 1:15 AM
order anafranil 50mg generic - buy duloxetine 20mg for sale cheap doxepin 75mg
Posted by: Nrxacu | March 30, 2024 12:01 AM
seroquel 50mg tablet - cheap eskalith pills cheap eskalith
Posted by: Gxsndg | March 30, 2024 12:17 AM
purchase atarax generic - buspirone oral purchase amitriptyline sale
Posted by: Vqiuiq | March 31, 2024 9:09 PM
amoxiclav tablet - buy septra paypal order cipro 500mg for sale
Posted by: Xcoyss | April 3, 2024 2:19 AM
amoxil for sale - cheap amoxil without prescription buy cheap generic baycip
Posted by: Mfavii | April 4, 2024 11:17 AM
azithromycin 500mg uk - tetracycline 500mg price order ciplox 500mg pills
Posted by: Lfkezm | April 9, 2024 12:59 AM
cost clindamycin - vantin 200mg generic buy chloromycetin for sale
Posted by: Cmvrio | April 9, 2024 10:52 PM
buy stromectol online - eryc cost cefaclor 250mg ca
Posted by: Rrzdii | April 11, 2024 5:45 PM
buy albuterol 4mg inhaler - advair diskus inhalator order online theophylline without prescription
Posted by: Tdasux | April 13, 2024 2:13 PM
buy medrol online - loratadine online where can i buy azelastine
Posted by: Madvds | April 14, 2024 5:42 PM
clarinex usa - order desloratadine 5mg sale albuterol drug
Posted by: Aihnrg | April 16, 2024 12:16 AM
cost micronase 2.5mg - order micronase 5mg online cheap forxiga order
Posted by: Yvqtvc | April 17, 2024 9:43 PM
brand prandin - buy empagliflozin paypal jardiance 25mg usa
Posted by: Zuykax | April 20, 2024 12:21 AM
oral semaglutide 14 mg - desmopressin drug DDAVP generic
Posted by: Vhmsue | April 21, 2024 8:27 PM
buy generic lamisil over the counter - buy grifulvin v for sale grifulvin v
Posted by: Kqqxtu | April 22, 2024 5:12 PM
buy ketoconazole 200mg for sale - purchase mentax online cheap sporanox 100 mg generic
Posted by: Rqgnom | April 24, 2024 7:47 PM
famvir 250mg canada - buy acyclovir 400mg online cheap valaciclovir 1000mg pills
Posted by: Omzevm | April 24, 2024 9:40 PM
buy generic lanoxin - avapro 300mg sale buy furosemide 100mg
Posted by: Hwmbai | April 26, 2024 10:31 PM
lopressor pill - generic lopressor buy nifedipine without prescription
Posted by: Dyjzzn | April 28, 2024 1:07 AM
buy microzide pills - bisoprolol 10mg pill order zebeta 5mg
Posted by: Vyezxc | April 29, 2024 12:09 AM
how to buy nitroglycerin - purchase catapres pills cost diovan
Posted by: Ftdghj | April 30, 2024 11:18 PM
simvastatin survey - fenofibrate move atorvastatin pray
Posted by: Qrtzpm | May 1, 2024 6:46 PM
rosuvastatin pills attic - caduet buy service caduet buy nice
Posted by: Bykrxn | May 3, 2024 3:42 PM
asthma treatment send - asthma medication misery inhalers for asthma throw
Posted by: Djxvga | May 19, 2024 5:20 PM
acne medication difficulty - acne medication moan acne medication prison
Posted by: Fzxrnu | May 20, 2024 6:57 AM
prostatitis medications age - prostatitis pills leg pills for treat prostatitis sad
Posted by: Gzypcm | May 21, 2024 2:01 PM
uti antibiotics just - uti medication temporary uti treatment shoe
Posted by: Zwywov | May 22, 2024 3:18 AM