« Book Review - The Tangled Bank | Main | New Comments »

Supreme Court Tells Christian Group to Follow the Same Rules as Everybody Else

A few weeks back, I blogged about a case going to the Supreme Court. To recap, the Hastings College of the Law in San Francisco had a policy that for any student group to be officially endorsed by the university and receive a small stipend, it couldn't restrict membership for any reason. One organization, the local Christian Legal Society (CLS), changed its rules to exclude homosexuals or those engaging in pre-marital sex from holding leadership positions or voting. The university enforced its policy, and revoked its official endorsement of the CLS. So, the CLS claimed discrimination, took the university to court, lost, and appealed to the Supreme Court.

In my original blog entry, I already explained why I thought the CLS was clearly wrong, so I wasn't surprised to read the headline, Justices Rule Against Group That Excludes Gay Students. What surprised me, perhaps because I'm still too politically naive, is how close the vote was: 5 to 4. Nearly half of the justices sided with the CLS.

Consider the following statement from Alito, who wrote the dissenting opinion, "I do not think it is an exaggeration to say that today's decision is a serious setback for freedom of expression in this country." To me, 'freedom of expression' means the ability to say something without interference. To Alito et al, 'freedom of expression' apparently means the ability to say something, get official government endorsement for that statement, and get taxpayer money to help you spread that statement. It's like words don't even have the same meaning to them. 'Freedom' and 'entitlement' are not the same thing.

I think Stevens put it best, saying "groups may exclude or mistreat Jews, Blacks and women or those who do not share their contempt for Jews, Blacks and women. A free society must tolerate such groups. It need not subsidize them, give them its official imprimatur, or grant them equal access to law school facilities."

The good news is that at least for now, a sensible decision was reached on this issue.


Let me just quote one section of the previous blog entry, to show why I think the CLS was so clearly wrong.

To be clear, the university did not ban the CLS from convening on campus, or ban students from joining the CLS, and did not even stop the CLS from using university facilities. They just didn't officially endorse the CLS and give it the stipend that official organizations receive.

Comments

order atorvastatin atorvastatin 80mg usa lipitor 20mg canada

purchase cipro online cheap - buy cephalexin augmentin 1000mg for sale

buy baycip without a prescription - keflex 500mg ca order augmentin 1000mg online

order metronidazole online - purchase azithromycin online zithromax 250mg cost

buy ciplox generic - tinidazole order online oral erythromycin 250mg

ivermectin 6 mg without prescription - buy axetil generic tetracycline online buy

order generic valacyclovir 500mg - buy valtrex 500mg online cheap acyclovir ca

order generic flagyl 400mg - oxytetracycline brand azithromycin 250mg uk

ampicillin tablet buy ampicillin generic cheap amoxil pills

lasix 100mg price - order candesartan without prescription order captopril for sale

buy glycomet online - combivir without prescription lincomycin 500mg pill

order retrovir 300 mg generic - roxithromycin 150 mg over the counter generic allopurinol 100mg

buy clozaril 50mg for sale - amaryl over the counter order famotidine for sale

buy quetiapine 50mg generic - venlafaxine generic eskalith online buy

order anafranil online cheap - paroxetine 20mg uk doxepin 25mg cost

brand hydroxyzine - order lexapro 20mg online cheap order endep pills

augmentin 375mg usa - buy generic ethambutol 1000mg order generic cipro 1000mg

amoxil pills - keflex tablet generic ciprofloxacin

zithromax online order - buy ofloxacin 200mg pill buy generic ciplox

order cleocin 300mg sale - oxytetracycline 250 mg for sale cheap chloramphenicol generic

ivermectin for humans for sale - doryx pill order cefaclor 500mg pill

buy albuterol generic - buy generic advair diskus inhalator buy generic theo-24 Cr 400 mg

order medrol - fluorometholone price astelin 10ml price

clarinex for sale - aristocort 4mg usa order albuterol 2mg online

order micronase 5mg generic - buy glyburide online generic dapagliflozin 10 mg

metformin 1000mg without prescription - glucophage us generic precose 50mg

order repaglinide 2mg online - order jardiance pills buy empagliflozin 10mg online cheap

order lamisil 250mg online - buy griseofulvin 250 mg for sale buy griseofulvin pills

purchase rybelsus sale - DDAVP ca purchase DDAVP online cheap

buy ketoconazole sale - lotrisone over the counter buy generic itraconazole 100mg

order famciclovir 250mg sale - buy generic acyclovir for sale order valaciclovir 1000mg generic

buy digoxin without prescription - labetalol 100 mg cost lasix online

order lopressor 100mg online - buy losartan medication buy nifedipine online cheap

order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online cheap - felodipine 5mg pills buy bisoprolol 5mg

buy nitroglycerin generic - buy valsartan 160mg online buy valsartan pill

crestor online footstep - rosuvastatin roof caduet online myth

zocor backward - zocor quest lipitor conclusion

acne treatment fetch - acne treatment rank acne medication colonel

inhalers for asthma relax - asthma treatment poor asthma treatment embrace

uti medication pole - uti medication misty treatment for uti woman

prostatitis medications cloud - pills for treat prostatitis luck prostatitis pills mask

Post a comment


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jefflewis.net/blog/jlnet-tb.cgi/311

Archives

Selling Out