Possibility of Evidence for Gods
There was a recent post on Pharyngula, prompted by a post on RichardDawkins.net written by Steve Zara. And in the time it's taken me to get this post written, there have been multiple follow ups on this subject:
- Jerry Coyne - Can there be evidence for God?
- PZ Myers - Eight reasons you won't persuade me to believe in a god
- Jerry Coyne - On P.Z. Myers on evidence for a god
- PZ Myers - There aren't any zogweebles, either
- Jerry Coyne - 115 years of debate about evidence for God
Let's look at what Zara wrote originally. In that article, he said:
I propose a new strident atheism. No playing the games of theists. No concessions. No talk of evidence that can change minds, when their beliefs are deliberately placed beyond logic, beyond evidence. Let's not get taken in by the fraud of religion. Let's not play their shell-game.
In agreement, Myers wrote this in his first post on the subject:
There is no possibility of evidence to convince us of the existence of a god.
I understand where they're coming from. They're frustrated with the theologian's god, the god that's so vague and nebulous that it might as well not exist, or, as I quoted Zara above, that's beyond logic and evidence.
But I think their position goes too far. To make the blanket statement that Myers did is close minded. While I don't believe that any gods exist, I can imagine a universe where they did, and imagine the types of things that the gods might do. To use an example from the comment thread on Pharyngula, if multiple astronomers somehow received a revelation of exactly when and where a supernova was going to occur (the comment used e-mail as the method of revelation), that would be a good piece of evidence for a god. If people were raised from the dead, or really could walk on water, or any of the points from Ebon Musing's Theist's Guide to Converting Atheists were demonstrated to be true, these would all be good evidence for the divine.
Zara brought up an interesting point, quoting Arthur C. Clarke's famous line, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." Even if we had the forms of evidence I listed above, how could we be sure that they were from a god, and not some advanced aliens messing around with us? Or how could we be sure that the responsible entity really was the creator of the universe, and not just some powerful force that came into being after the big bang (a la His Dark Materials or Star Trek V). Even without invoking such god like beings, fulfilled prophecies could just be interpreted as psychic abilities of humans, and some other miracles could be telekinesis, or some other as yet unknown force. This was the direction Myers went in his defense in his follow up posts.
While they're interesting possibities to think about, they're still hypothetical, since nobody has yet seen any real miracles that couldn't be explained with what we already know about the universe. Until someone actually produces an accurate prophecy, there's no need to speculate whether it's a psychic ability of humans, an inspiration from the divine, or aliens beaming signals into our heads. Until we actually hear a voice boom down from the heavens, we don't need to try to figure out if it's Zeus or and Interstellar construction crew. It's a bit pointless trying to come up with explanations for things that haven't happened.
This leads into another point where I have the most sympathy with Myers' and Zara's position. If the types of evidence I listed above had been happening throughout recorded history, that would be one thing. However, considering that there's been no credible evidence for the divine for basically the entire history of human civilization, it would certainly make one question the source if this evidence suddenly began appearing all over the place. Given the choice between 'God thought it was finally time to interact with his creation after 14 billion years of hands off observation', vs. 'a space faring civilization has just now encountered our solar system', the latter seems more likely.
So, in sympathy with Zara and Myers, I can say that no single piece of evidence would instantly convince me that gods exist. There's just too long a history of lack of evidence, and too many alternate explanations for any single phenomenon. However, I won't go so far as to say that I couldn't ever be convinced. Given enough evidence from multiple lines, I would seriously consider the possibility that they were divine in origin. I'm just waiting for somebody to actually show me that evidence.
In anticipation of those people who would simply ask me to read the Gospels for examples of miracles, I'll direct them to a previous blog entry of mine, Liar, Lunatic, or Lord... Or Something Else, for a short description of why I don't think the Gospels are reliable. For a bit of a humorous take on other arguments people use for a god's existence that aren't very convincing, take a look at the Hundreds of Proofs of God's Existence on GodlessGeeks.com.
Comments
purchase lipitor lipitor 20mg cost atorvastatin 40mg cheap
Posted by: Pgfcse | March 12, 2024 1:05 PM
atorvastatin 80mg drug buy generic atorvastatin buy lipitor paypal
Posted by: Aitnub | March 12, 2024 1:56 PM
buy generic ciprofloxacin online - keflex 500mg us buy augmentin 1000mg without prescription
Posted by: Keupfv | March 14, 2024 2:31 AM
baycip buy online - oral augmentin 375mg augmentin without prescription
Posted by: Ewtcfb | March 15, 2024 8:21 AM
order ciprofloxacin 500mg sale - buy chloramphenicol generic buy erythromycin online cheap
Posted by: Fybefs | March 17, 2024 6:39 AM
purchase flagyl pills - buy amoxicillin paypal order zithromax generic
Posted by: Loimbs | March 18, 2024 5:07 AM
ivermectin 3mg - order sumycin online cheap purchase tetracycline sale
Posted by: Zmtogi | March 19, 2024 10:31 AM
order generic valacyclovir 1000mg - valacyclovir 500mg uk buy acyclovir 800mg pill
Posted by: Hdoaqa | March 20, 2024 10:30 AM
buy ampicillin pills acillin without prescription amoxil medication
Posted by: Rdnhej | March 21, 2024 11:17 AM
metronidazole pills - order terramycin 250 mg sale order azithromycin generic
Posted by: Wqdxhd | March 22, 2024 4:11 AM
purchase furosemide - order prograf 1mg online capoten 25 mg for sale
Posted by: Vmyoyt | March 24, 2024 2:00 AM
where can i buy glucophage - duricef 250mg generic how to buy lincocin
Posted by: Wiygvu | March 25, 2024 6:54 AM
buy clozapine online - buy famotidine 40mg for sale buy pepcid 40mg for sale
Posted by: Gfurix | March 27, 2024 4:08 PM
order zidovudine generic - order epivir 100mg sale zyloprim 300mg tablet
Posted by: Zplbgf | March 27, 2024 5:13 PM
buy anafranil paypal - buy imipramine 75mg for sale pill sinequan 25mg
Posted by: Ctjcit | March 30, 2024 8:15 AM
buy seroquel pills - seroquel 100mg cost buy eskalith for sale
Posted by: Wljbdj | March 30, 2024 1:46 PM
atarax 10mg price - order escitalopram 20mg generic endep sale
Posted by: Bnjkrt | April 1, 2024 8:08 AM
buy augmentin 625mg online cheap - amoxiclav tablet order baycip generic
Posted by: Pibnju | April 3, 2024 10:39 AM
buy amoxil generic - amoxil pills where can i buy ciprofloxacin
Posted by: Rgymjy | April 4, 2024 11:49 PM
azithromycin online order - buy sumycin generic brand ciplox 500 mg
Posted by: Shfclv | April 9, 2024 9:15 AM
buy generic cleocin over the counter - buy generic oxytetracycline 250mg cheap chloromycetin
Posted by: Wgefmp | April 10, 2024 12:38 PM
stromectol pharmacy - ivermectin 3 mg over counter buy cefaclor 250mg for sale
Posted by: Osbnca | April 12, 2024 2:10 AM
order albuterol online - albuterol inhalator for sale buy theophylline without prescription
Posted by: Zffrzg | April 14, 2024 3:07 AM
medrol 16 mg without a doctor prescription - cheap astelin order astelin 10 ml
Posted by: Ldvqio | April 15, 2024 2:13 AM
clarinex over the counter - buy cheap desloratadine buy ventolin generic
Posted by: Zafsck | April 16, 2024 1:37 PM
glyburide 5mg for sale - order pioglitazone 15mg sale buy forxiga 10 mg pills
Posted by: Fkumno | April 18, 2024 9:50 AM
repaglinide 1mg sale - prandin 1mg generic buy generic jardiance
Posted by: Hfxcmq | April 20, 2024 3:14 PM
semaglutide 14mg ca - desmopressin ca desmopressin spray
Posted by: Nlawdl | April 22, 2024 5:20 AM
buy famciclovir 500mg online cheap - purchase valaciclovir valcivir order
Posted by: Nbjmli | April 25, 2024 6:54 AM
buy nizoral cheap - buy lotrisone generic buy sporanox paypal
Posted by: Jqufyg | April 25, 2024 8:58 AM
oral digoxin 250mg - dipyridamole 100mg tablet furosemide 40mg uk
Posted by: Dfxpjy | April 27, 2024 11:35 AM
buy lopressor no prescription - generic micardis 20mg adalat ca
Posted by: Piljcd | April 28, 2024 10:18 AM
buy microzide without prescription - buy zestril pills for sale buy cheap generic bisoprolol
Posted by: Fjrzmb | April 29, 2024 1:26 PM
nitroglycerin over the counter - catapres online diovan 160mg us
Posted by: Bkugge | May 1, 2024 12:58 PM
zocor swear - simvastatin bridge lipitor pale
Posted by: Wtquut | May 2, 2024 3:21 AM
crestor pills urge - rosuvastatin online offer caduet online when
Posted by: Idwspz | May 4, 2024 4:06 AM
asthma treatment sniff - asthma medication gaunt asthma treatment consult
Posted by: Dohcwz | May 20, 2024 12:11 AM
acne medication scarlet - acne medication pirate acne treatment pride
Posted by: Bruvhr | May 20, 2024 5:16 PM
prostatitis pills former - pills for treat prostatitis pony prostatitis treatment cup
Posted by: Idlrgz | May 21, 2024 9:10 PM
uti treatment assure - treatment for uti indeed treatment for uti examine
Posted by: Kihrqw | May 22, 2024 12:39 PM