« Microsoft Security Not So Bad? | Main | Website Update- New Info on Factoid Page »

Moral Absolutism vs. Relativism

Reading a recent entry on Pharyngula, I came across a quote from Kirk Cameron that struck me (not because it was Kirk Cameron saying it, but because the topic is a typical view), "Atheism has become very popular in universities--where it's taught that we evolved from animals and that there are no moral absolutes. So we shouldn't be surprised when there are school shootings." Well, the school shooting part's a complete non-sequitir. But I do want to take a look at the moral absolute parts in a bit more detail. There seems to be a sense among many Christians in this country that morals are absolute, and moral relativism is a bad, bad thing.

Now, I'll admit right up front that philosophy isn't my area of expertise, so perhaps my Wikipedia informed definitions of moral absolutism and moral relativism is leading me astray, but it certainly seems to me that most of our morals are relative, and not absolute. Even for Christians, when you look at the 10 commandments, the ones that deal with how to treat other people can all be looked at on a relative basis.

Honor your father and your mother.
What about if your parents tell you to worship Ganesh? What if your parents snap, and go on a murderous rampage - should you try to stop them, or honor their wishes and let them kill more people?
You shall not kill [sometimes translated as murder].
Is it okay to kill someone in self defense? Execute a convicted murderer? Kill people in war? Shoot a person on a murderous rampage?
You shall not commit adultery.
Well - from the Christian perspective, there's not much to argue with in this one, but what about cultures where it's okay for spouses to have sex outside marriage, as long as neither spouse has a problem with it?
You shall not steal.
Is it wrong to steal food to feed your starving children? Is it bad to steal a gun from a murderer so that he can't shoot anybody else?
You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.
Is it okay to lie to a murderer so that he can't find his next victim?
You shall not covet your neighbor's house; you shall not covet your neighbor's wife, nor his male servant, nor his female servant, nor his ox, nor his donkey, nor anything that is your neighbor's.
Well, this doesn't exactly cover directly dealing with other people. It's just good advice not to be jealous.

I guess Christians could still argue that certain actions besides those listed above are inherently good or bad, but the Christian basis for good or bad a lot of times simply boils down to "God said so," but this doesn't say that the actions themselves are inherently good or bad. For a popular example, look at eating kosher foods. Before Jesus, it was apparently immoral to eat non-Kosher foods, but now, because of the New Covenant, non-Kosher foods (like shrimp) are on the menu. So, there was nothing inherent in the action that was moral or immoral, just whether or not God said it was okay. To insist on moral relativism absolutism, when it seems that even God himself can change his mind, seems like a pretty strong stance to take.

A lot of Christians in this country today argue that morals are absolute, but it seems to me that the morality of an action really must be determined in context, and that most people usually do judge actions that way. To insist on complete moral absolutism seems a bit silly.


I'm about to do an exam on this- thanks for the information.

atorvastatin 80mg ca atorvastatin 80mg ca order lipitor 20mg online cheap

order ciprofloxacin 1000mg pill - order cipro 500mg generic cost amoxiclav

cost ciprofloxacin - purchase cephalexin pills buy augmentin generic

buy ciplox 500 mg without prescription - order tindamax 500mg generic erythromycin over the counter

flagyl price - buy metronidazole 200mg pills zithromax us

where to buy stromectol - amoxiclav us buy sumycin 500mg

buy generic valtrex over the counter - valacyclovir drug acyclovir 400mg canada

where can i buy ampicillin purchase ampicillin without prescription cheap amoxil generic

metronidazole 200mg cheap - buy cefaclor 500mg sale azithromycin 250mg oral

order furosemide 40mg online cheap - order candesartan 16mg generic captopril 25 mg

order metformin pills - buy lincomycin pill buy lincocin 500 mg online cheap

retrovir 300 mg cost - allopurinol drug

buy clozapine online cheap - famotidine 40mg cheap purchase famotidine generic

seroquel where to buy - brand quetiapine 50mg oral eskalith

order anafranil 50mg pills - brand abilify 30mg buy sinequan 75mg for sale

hydroxyzine 25mg without prescription - nortriptyline 25mg without prescription endep uk

brand amoxiclav - brand myambutol 1000mg cheap ciprofloxacin 500mg

amoxil online buy - cheap erythromycin 250mg order ciprofloxacin generic

buy zithromax pills - floxin online ciprofloxacin cheap

order cleocin online - order chloramphenicol pills buy chloromycetin generic

ivermectin 12 mg tablets - buy eryc 500mg for sale order cefaclor 250mg for sale

order ventolin inhalator sale - theophylline order buy theo-24 Cr 400 mg generic

buy methylprednisolone medication - methylprednisolone 16mg over the counter order azelastine 10 ml sale

order clarinex 5mg generic - buy triamcinolone 4mg generic brand albuterol 4mg

order micronase pills - order glucotrol dapagliflozin order online

glycomet buy online - order hyzaar online order acarbose 50mg sale

prandin 2mg cost - buy generic repaglinide 2mg empagliflozin order online

buy generic rybelsus over the counter - order desmopressin for sale order desmopressin generic

terbinafine oral - griseofulvin 250 mg uk grifulvin v online

buy ketoconazole online - order generic ketoconazole order sporanox 100mg sale

order famvir generic - buy acyclovir without a prescription valcivir 1000mg pills

purchase lanoxin without prescription - generic calan lasix 100mg brand

order metoprolol 100mg without prescription - oral cozaar buy nifedipine 30mg for sale

buy hydrochlorothiazide generic - buy prinivil without prescription zebeta online

buy nitroglycerin without prescription - buy clonidine pills oral valsartan 160mg

simvastatin trap - fenofibrate bedroom atorvastatin thoughtful

rosuvastatin aim - pravastatin buy patience caduet candle

asthma medication linger - inhalers for asthma bill inhalers for asthma particular

acne treatment because - acne treatment nevertheless acne treatment dreadful

prostatitis treatment tap - prostatitis medications loose prostatitis pills gleam

uti antibiotics land - treatment for uti attach treatment for uti reality

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out