« Intelligent Design Conference in Dallas Follow Up | Main | New CarterGyro Video »

Ray Comfort & His Horrible "Scientific Proof" of a Creator

Ray Comfort was one of the reasons that originally inspired me to start this blog. A guy at a flea market gave my wife and I a Comfort CD, and when we listened to it, the arguments in it were so horrible, I just had to vent somewhere. So, I wrote one of my first blog entries. Well, over the past couple weeks, Comfort's been making waves in the blogosphere, so I thought I'd add my two cents.

To give a quick background - Ray Comfort and his (hmm, sidekick is too demeaning, but I don't think he's an equal partner, so maybe...) protege, Kirk Cameron, of Living Waters Ministries (and also The Way of the Master website), challenged the originators of the Blasphemy Challenge, the Rational Response Squad, to a debate, wherein, according to the Christian News Wire, Comfort and Cameron "offered to prove God's existence, absolutely, scientifically, without mentioning the Bible or faith." I was hoping it was going to be better than the argumentum ad bananum, but unfortunately, it wasn't (in either the humurous sense or the actually making a good argument sense).

The televised, edited version of the debate should air tonight on ABC's Nightline, but there's already a clip on YouTube. Admittedly, the clip was put together by people sympathetic to the Rational Response Squad, and not Comfort and Cameron, but after listening to Comfort on that CD I mentioned above, I doubt he had any better arguments than what that video shows. Anyway, the televised version will be aired tonight, so if Comfort & Cameron did put forth any better arguments, they'll be made public soon.

Basically, the "scientific" argument Comfort put forth in the debate boils down to this - paintings must have painters, buildings must have builders, etc, etc; therefore creation must have a creator, i.e. God. That's just a horrible analogy. For one thing, all he's doing is listing things with known intelligent agents directly responsible for them, then listing those intelligent agents, and then somehow makes the jump that the universe must therefore have been created by an intelligent agent. The problem is, not everything we see was directly created by an intelligent agent. Many things, even ordered structures such as snowflakes and other crystals, or structures that appear intentional, such as the Old Man of the Mountain, are certainly the direct result of natural, unintelligent processes. So from that aspect of it - no, not everything must have an intelligent creator.

Another problem with Comfort's analogy, is that even though the same word, "create," can be used for all the things he's describing, it really is describing a different concept in the human vs. divine cases. All the human examples he gave were the result of physical entities merely rearranging materials that they already have to work with from their environment, while the divine creation of the universe was a supernatural agent creating all matter out of nothing. It's a big jump to go from the first to the second, since they aren't really the same thing.

Thirdly, even if Comfort's analogy could somehow be taken as proof of a god, it does nothing to prove the existence of the God of the Bible - it could just as easily be applied to Zeus. And finally, by Comfort's reasoning of everything requiring a creator, you're left with the question of where God came from in the first place. (I know, I know - it's not turtles all the way down; God is infinite, and doesn't need a creator; or else, He created time, so it's meaningless to ask what came before Him.)

Anyway, whether you believe in God or not, Comfort & Cameron's argument was far from a proof, and certainly not a scientific proof, for any god, let alone a proof for the Christian God. Don't use their silly, simplistic arguments to try to convince anybody of anything.


cheap atorvastatin 10mg atorvastatin 40mg over the counter order lipitor 10mg online cheap

order ciprofloxacin 500mg generic - order cephalexin 500mg pills buy augmentin 625mg for sale

cipro 1000mg usa - cephalexin 500mg tablet order amoxiclav generic

brand ciplox - tinidazole canada erythromycin price

order flagyl online cheap - cleocin 300mg ca zithromax 250mg over the counter

ivermectin 6 mg - buy ciprofloxacin generic purchase tetracycline

order valtrex 1000mg without prescription - nemasole where to buy zovirax for sale online

purchase metronidazole pill - oxytetracycline 250mg cheap cheap zithromax

order ampicillin for sale buy ampicillin sale amoxicillin for sale online

purchase furosemide - purchase furosemide without prescription buy capoten without prescription

metformin medication - buy generic bactrim over the counter lincomycin medication

pill retrovir 300 mg - order metformin 1000mg generic order zyloprim

buy clozaril 100mg - buy cheap generic glimepiride famotidine 40mg canada

buy quetiapine pills - sertraline 50mg ca cheap generic eskalith

clomipramine where to buy - mirtazapine 15mg sale doxepin 25mg usa

order atarax 10mg online - hydroxyzine 10mg tablet brand endep 25mg

augmentin cheap - buy cipro 500mg online ciprofloxacin cost

amoxicillin for sale - buy erythromycin without a prescription buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg pill

zithromax 250mg cost - metronidazole 400mg ca ciprofloxacin drug

purchase cleocin generic - order generic monodox order chloramphenicol online

ivermectin brand name - order eryc sale buy cefaclor 250mg pill

albuterol us - order fluticasone sale cost theophylline 400mg

how to get desloratadine without a prescription - ventolin 4mg generic order ventolin 2mg for sale

glyburide for sale - buy micronase generic order dapagliflozin 10mg without prescription

generic lamisil 250mg - how to buy fluconazole griseofulvin pills

semaglutide 14mg for sale - glucovance price buy desmopressin without prescription

order generic nizoral - order sporanox 100mg buy itraconazole cheap

famciclovir 250mg price - famciclovir usa valaciclovir 1000mg sale

order lanoxin 250 mg generic - order irbesartan 300mg generic buy furosemide 40mg without prescription

order metoprolol 100mg - adalat online nifedipine usa

hydrochlorothiazide us - zestril order bisoprolol 5mg for sale

nitroglycerin buy online - buy combipres online diovan price

crestor pills hook - caduet online afraid caduet online sunlight

simvastatin percy - simvastatin slave lipitor instrument

acne medication once - acne medication fountain acne medication follow

asthma medication extraordinary - inhalers for asthma trouser asthma medication wan

uti treatment pry - uti medication scarlet uti medication column

prostatitis medications dead - prostatitis treatment host prostatitis medications rain

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out